Pros & Cons Of The 3 Most Popular Roof Types

Weathered Cedar Shakes
Weathered Cedar Shakes

If you’re thinking of replacing your roof or are building a new roof on a new home, you’ll likely find yourself choosing one of these roof materials.

The reason why these are so popular isn’t complicated, Asphalt Shingles are great for the budget-minded, while metal roofs and cedar shakes/shingles are available for those who need a stronger roof or want a specific look

Whatever you choose, each has pro’s and con’s depending on your home and budget:

Asphalt Shingles

The most common residential roof type by far, asphalt shingles has many advantages that justify it’s top spot.

Pros:

  • The most affordable of all the roof types, they start cheap with 3-tab shingles and go all the way to designer shingles that replicate more expensive roof types like cedar shakes.
  • Looks great on most any home.
  • Relatively easy to repair and maintain (if inspected regularly)
  • East to install with most installations taking just a couple of days.
  • Plenty of variety, even the pickiest of homeowners can find something they like.
  • Lightweight and durable

Cons:

  • Especially susceptible to wind and hail damage
  • Moss & mildew grow easily on asphalt shingles
  • Compared to other roof types has a short lifespan, requiring replacement every 15- 30 years.

Metal Roofs

Pros:

  • Can last as long as the house or building itself
  • Shrugs off wind and rain like it never happened, especially durable
  • Mildew, mold, rot, even fire doesn’t phase a metal roof, it’s resistance to these is legendary.

Cons;

  • The most expensive of the 3 common roof types both in terms of materials and labor
  • Hail damage may not affect the integrity of a metal roof, it can leave ugly dents.
  • Can be loud during rains although roof contractors can mitigate this with various methods to dampen the noise.
  • Repairs can be expensive. Although metal roofs are extremely durable, if a repair needs to be performed it can be quite expensive compared to it’s asphalt shingle cousins.

Cedar Shakes/Cedar Shingles

Pros:

  • Extremely durable. highly resistant to wind and rain
  • Properly maintained, cedar shakes/shingles can last several decades or more.
  • Looks great to many (beauty is in the eye of the beholder of course)
  • Actually looks better (again subjective) as it ages

Cons:

  • Material is more expensive as is labor as each shake must be installed individually.
  • Also susceptible to moss, mold, and mildew, homeowners must strictly adhere to a regular maintenance schedule. Individual shakes should be replaced by a roof contractor as soon as they need to.

No matter what you choose, a roof is only as good as it’s installation. Be sure you hire a qualified roof contractor to install your new roof to help ensure it’s as trouble-free as possible  for the life of the roof.

For more information on roof types or to obtain a free estimate on your roof project in Metro Atlanta call Atlanta Roofing Specialists at 770-419-2222 today!

Atlanta Roofing Specialists is a full service residential and commercial roofing company serving Metro Atlanta since 1993. Call (770) 419-2222 today to schedule your personalized inspection!

Popular Post

A commercial flat roof, as seen in a blog answering, "how long does a flat roof last​"

How Long Does a Flat Roof Last in Atlanta?

The short answer to, “How long does a flat roof last?” is 15 to 30 years for most systems. The material on the roof accounts for much of that spread

New Metal Roof, as seen in a blog questioning "Are metal roofs loud?"

Are Metal Roofs Loud During Storms? How Roofing Systems Reduce Noise

If you are thinking about metal roofing for your home, one concern may come up early: are metal roofs loud when it rains or storms? A properly installed residential metal

Skylight installation in response to the question, "how much does it cost to install a skylight​?"

How Much Does It Cost to Install a Skylight? 7 Factors That Affect the Price

If you’re asking, “How much does it cost to install a skylight?”, a reasonable starting budget is around $1,000 to $3,000 or more for professional installation. A simple fixed skylight